My wife and I wanted a Date Night since I just returned from a month long job out of town. We have had their pizza delivered or take-out before but never had eaten here. My wife had the Three Cousins and it was fabulous! Veal, Chicken and Eggplant Parm with a very good sauce and spaghetti. Pasta was perfect. Bread was excellent. Ceasar Salad was good. The wine we chose was excellent and our waitress was excellent in her duties as well. I ordered Frutti de Mare Fra Diavalo. When it came I tasted the sauce and it was excellent. I had requested it be VERY SPICY and they had done very well. Where the cook did not do very well is the two mussels and one clam that did not open when cooked. I realized the problem when I was taking everything out of shells before eating and I sent it back. Our waitress was very quick to offer to make up another batch but I was completely turned off by then and I didn't trust the situation. It was late on a Friday night and if people were in that much of a hurry as to miss a severe problem that is that obvious they certainly didn't even look. Our waitress told me the cook had offered to come out and speak to me about this but I told her it was not necessary. My wife and I split some of her dish and we left. This was really a 5/1 star experience and I am not sure what else to say honestly about it and I am not sure we will return.

Jennifer was an attentive server and the pizza was good. The salad was just a little bland...could have used some croutons or cheese. Wish they would go to a house made house dressing.

Stopped in on a whim for lunch. Oh my, what a treat! Service was excellent and the food was out of this world. A nice variety of pizza for slices, house made salad dressing, and a meatball sub big enough for two lunches. True New York style pizza, and a locally owned business (not a chain) is enough to lead me to consider moving. I'm a pizza snob and it was so good, we had to order it for dinner two days later (the Mulberry Street! Yum!!) Don't miss out on this hidden gem tucked in next to Publix.

This was our second visit. We ate here a couple months ago and tried some dinner dishes, that were excellent, so we went back to try the pizza. I loved it. nice thin crust (but it was a little chewier then I would like it) , good quality cheese ( I like it when it stretches when you bit into it. lol) My boyfriend said the crust lacked some flavor, but it was otherwise very good. We also got a sampler appetizer with Mozzarella sticks; fried ravioli; fried portobella strips & Zucchini fries. The Mozz sticks were perfect and I loved the zucchini, I couldn't stop eating them. The ravioli was just ok, I think maybe a little over cooked and the Portobella was just ok too. nothing really wrong with it, just wasn't super crazy about it.
We will go back for sure. Dinners and pizza are good; which ever we get, I will get the fried Zucchini again...
Neither time did we save room for dessert, so next time we will have to make sure we stop eating before we get too full, lol.
Staff was nice, but we sat next to the service bar (where the drinks are poured; dressings ect) and the door to the kitchen because it was cold inside and was the only available spot that didn't have a vent blowing right on us :( so the spot wasn't the greatest to sit, but we tried not to pay attention. The last time we were here, we had a nice spot in the main dinning area, so that time was nice.

I am a native Floridian and have spent most of my life in this area. Years and years ago, there was a pizza place called Sir Pizza. It was on 17-92 in Winter Park, FL and was great. When they went out of business, we couldn't find another comparable place.

I had been watching people coming in and out of this little pizza place. It was always busy, but it didn't look like a place where I would find great pizza. Here's a little advice: do not judge a book by its cover. Let me just tell you. The pizza is fabulous!!! The salad is wonderful (as is the dressing). The homemade bread is to die for. All in all, Anthony's Pizza is a real find, and now I understand why there is always traffic in and out of there.

You expect for business to be good on Friday and Saturday, but you can go in there on a Tuesday evening, and all the tables are full and there are people waiting for to go orders.

It's an unassuming place, but there food is fabulous! You can't go wrong ordering from this Anthony's Pizza in Casselberry—not to be confused with other Anthony's Pizza places elsewhere in Central Florida. Like the title says Yum, yum, yum!!!!!!