Four of us ordered different dishes and everyone was extremely happy with the food and service. My son’s steak was cooked perfectly as was our fish.
Four of us ordered different dishes and everyone was extremely happy with the food and service. My son’s steak was cooked perfectly as was our fish.
Aloha, We’re happy to hear that your family’s meal was a fantastic 5-stars! Mahalo for dining with us and we look forward to seeing you and the ‘ohana again soon. - Nick’s
Perfect dinner! Tristan provided exceptional service and made it the best dinner we’ve had this year on Maui. Don’t miss the beet and strawberry salad!
Aloha Mary, Mahalo for dining with us at Nick’s Fishmarket and we’re happy to hear about Tristan’s exceptional service. Please join us again soon. - Nick’s
Excellent food. We all had catch of the day and it was perfect. Great waiter and multiple options for all kinds of eaters. Great sunset view too
Aloha Lauretta, Thank you for the perfect 5-stars. We were pleased to hear you enjoyed the catch of the day and that our service exceeded your expectations. We love the sunset views as well. Please visit us again soon for another great meal. - Nick’s
I can't express enough the love and thoughtfulness that went into my experience. Tia and Nika the hostesses were exceptional. Table was amazing. Pre cocktail at the bar w Jason and Dave was just how to start the night. Speedy and tasty. Our waiter Chevis...1st and foremost CONGRATS ON CHEVIS JR!. Hope to meet the extended fam w our next visit. Will return n hope to see you all, even Jack who wasnt our waiter but took extra effort to insure our dinning experience was above any and all others. Till then keep up the bar of elegance and exceptional service.More
Aloha, Thank you for the kind compliments about our team! We appreciate all our happy customers. We hope you’ll join us again for another great meal, Nick’s.
Beautiful setting and food plating. The portion size was good. The colossal shrimp was overcooked and the appetizer and dessert were ok. The service was lacking. Our server didn't come around often and we had to ask for our bill twice.More
Aloha Juan, Thank you for taking the time to write this review. We’re glad you like the table setting and food portion sizes. We’re sorry that we couldn’t provide the best experience for you at your recent visit. We hope that you’ll give us another...More
Located in the Fairmont Kea Lani means you can expect high quality and high prices and you won't be disappointed on either score. Check the menu prices before you go! If you don't mind the cost, you should be pleasantly surprised by the quality. I...have nothing but praise for the location, service, view, and especially the delicious meal, and yes I had a nightly fresh fish special (Monchong on ferro with broccolini), wine, and dessert. All top notch. I look forward to going back soon.More
We are happy to hear that you enjoyed our food and customer service! It’s a pleasure to serve our guests at Nick’s. Thank you for choosing to dine with us. Sincerely, Nick’s Fishmarket Maui.
My husband and I ate out about a dozen times in Wailea recently. My favorite meal was when we arrived at Nick’s Fish House at 5 pm and sat at the bar. (No reservation needed). Bartenders Jason and Dave are still there, and they are...the best. My husband ordered several delicious items off the bar menu and I had the best mahi mahi of my life from the main menu. In 50 minutes we were done and paid up in time to walk down to see a beautiful sunset. Perfect night.More
Aloha Leslie, we'll see you again soon for another visit!
This is one of our favorite restaurants in Wailea, Maui. The food is always good and service is impeccable. The staff do a great job of making you feel special. Chris was of server and he is a RockStar.
Aloha, so glad that we could be your favorite. Thank you for the kind comments about our team! Take care, Nick's.
Honestly, we used to love this place. We would go out of our way to go here, but so much has changed…. The server we had recently was trying to act slick and funny but came across as a cheesy used car salesperson on coke....Not the type of server we expect when paying $300 plus for just the two of us. It used to be a classy place, but when you look around, the staff aren’t engaged and no one really seems to be happy to be there. We certainly weren’t, as much as we wanted to be…. The food was not what it used to be, and it’s just left us questioning if we need to ever go back. There’s not much to rave about any more and seriously, if you take some time to read through the reviews, others are feeling the same. Hoping things change but it would take a lot to bring Nicks back to what it was.More
Aloha we5tcoast, mahalo for your honest feedback. We will take your comments in review. It is our goal to provide quality service and food to our customers, and we appreciate your patience on this. Mahalo, Nick's.
The food was great!!! We got the lobster and filet mignon. Highly recommend those dishes. It was a 300 dollar bill after tax and tip. So super pricey! The service was below average for us that night. They were busy and it took forever to...get menus and bread and drinks, etc. The drinks were mediocre, but the food made up for it.More
Aloha Honeymooner231, thank you for your feedback, we have taken note and hope to see again for another visit. Best regards, Nick’s Fishmarket
Nicks is always a good choice for fresh fish and a good meal. What really bothers me is the kitchen surcharge on my bill. I asked why and was told” this goes direct to pay the cooks since Covid” I said Covid was 3 years...ago and why doesn’t the owner pay the cooks more. Why pass the customer the burden of paying your staff to cook the food I’m already paying top dollar for? I hate being nickel and dimed. They never took off the charge and was told they would discuss it next meeting but it was the owners decision not his(manager)More
Aloha, we've taken note of your comments and thoughts regarding the surcharge. We hope that you’ll consider dining with us again soon. Sincerely, Nick’s Fishmarket Maui.
What a great experience! My husband made reservations at Nick’s before we left for Maui. We loved the service and the food. Given we had a heavy lunch, we ordered some mocktails and the strawberry + beet salad followed by the avocado mujadra. Everything was...delicious and we enjoyed the ambience of an outdoor table.More
Aloha 68lesleyb, we are happy to hear that you enjoyed your evening with us! It’s a pleasure to serve our guests at Nick’s. Thank you for choosing to dine with us. Sincerely, Nick’s Fishmarket Maui.
We used to go to Nick's regularly, prior to the pandemic. This was our first time back in several years and it was a bit disappointing. We were there with our family to celebrate our 25th wedding anniversary. The food was pretty good (try the...oysters!) but the service was lacking. In our past experiences, the service had always been fantastic. Your water glass was never empty, there were always several staff members around waiting to fulfill your needs. But this time was very different. Service was slow and not at all of the friendly kind we were used to. Several times, we had to flag someone down to ask for cutlery or another drink. It was still a nice evening but if you're looking for a complete fine dining experience, you can do better elsewhere.More
Aloha C181LVlaurak, we appreciate you stopping by Nick’s Fishmarket for dinner. It is our commitment to ensure that guests have a great dining experience, and we are sorry to have let you down. We will take your comments into consideration in making positive changes for...More
If you are looking for a romantic dinner for the two of you, or just some really great seafood, then Nick’s Fishmarket is the place. The atmosphere is that of calm and elegant with the food being a mix of surf and turf. The menu...will change depending on the season but the Mahi Mahi is a flaky piece of heaven during any season and their crab cakes are some of the best we ever had. It was a nice date place for the two of us and one we could never forget. Kid friendly kid menu $$$More
Thank you so much for the 5! We appreciate your review and we'll share it with our team. We look forward to dining with you again soon!
My husband and I made a reservation here for our last night in Maui based on the menu and great food reviews. The experience was dampened greatly by the number of BABIES and small children in the restaurant. One table allowed their kids to run...in and out of the restaurant during their dinner. The tables behind us had babies yelling or crying. One would think that this restaurant and the Fairmont Kea Lani was a Disney resort. If it were advertised as such, we would never had made reservations here! Who brings their small and/or unruly kids to a 5-star establishment not thinking for a minute of the disturbance they cause to people who pay a lot of money for a 5-star experience? A good restaurant requires a wonderful menu, friendly hostesses, great wait staff and an amazing environment. If one is bad, the whole experience is bad. The environment was terrible. So, overall, a tremendous disappointment!More
Aloha H4349FWmaryw, thank you for choosing to dine with us and leaving us a review. We appreciate your honest feedback and will share with our team to continue to improve. We hope that you’ll give us a second chance to provide the quality dining experience...More