10 Best Hotels near Pigeon Key, Marathon
Hotels near Pigeon Key
The island of Pigeon Key is a historic 5-acre island located in the heart of the Florida Keys! It was once the home of over 400 workers who built the Overseas Railway from Miami to Key West. Today, the island is operated by the Pigeon Key Foundation, a 501(c)-3 not for profit organization. Our Visitor's Center, which is the address listed, is where our trains depart from at 10am, 12pm, and 2pm. Visitors can take part in our guided historical tour, pack a picnic, enjoy our beach front, snorkel or fish (must bring your own gear) or explore on their own. The possibilities are endless and the visit is perfect for people of all ages. Bring the family or your friends to enjoy paradise! Check out our website or call our Gift Shop for more information about this hidden gem in Marathon.
Read more
1090 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Read Reviews of Pigeon Key
Popular
AwardsTravellers’ Choice Awards winners (including the “Best of the Best” title) are among the top 10% of listings on Tripadvisor, according to the reviews and opinions of travellers across the globe.
Property types
Amenities
Distance from
25+ km
Traveller rating
Hotel class
Style
Brands
Searching hundreds of travel sites to find you the best price
Sort by:
- Best ValueProperties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveller ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
- Traveller RankedHighest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveller reviews.
- Distance from Pigeon KeySee properties located closest to the place of interest first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners.
- Highest-rated 5-star hotel within 21 km of Pigeon KeyBased on availability on Tripadvisor for 20 October - 21 OctoberEnter dates to see prices58182 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 3305021.2 km from Pigeon Key#1 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesResort58743 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 3305022.0 km from Pigeon Key#2 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices13201 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 3305014.1 km from Pigeon Key#3 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see prices13351 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 3305014.3 km from Pigeon Key#6 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesSmall Hotel1275 76th Street Ocean East, Marathon, FL 33050-31319.9 km from Pigeon Key#7 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesMotel57784 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050-562620.7 km from Pigeon Key#8 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices2146 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 330505.3 km from Pigeon Key#9 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesResort2600 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050-22435.6 km from Pigeon Key#10 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices19 Sombrero Blvd, Marathon, FL 33050-24087.6 km from Pigeon Key#11 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesSmall Hotel12020 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050-352513.3 km from Pigeon Key#12 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see pricesResort1 Knights Key Blvd Mm 47, Marathon, FL 33050-20023.6 km from Pigeon Key#14 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesResort3800 Gulfview Avenue, Marathon, FL 330506.6 km from Pigeon Key#15 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices4590 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 330507.3 km from Pigeon Key#16 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesApartment11600 1st Avenue Gulf, Marathon, FL 33050-500112.9 km from Pigeon Key#17 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see pricesSmall Hotel7196 Overseas Hwy Mile Marker 51, Marathon, FL 33050-31389.4 km from Pigeon Key#20 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesMotel7050 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050-31409.4 km from Pigeon Key#21 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesSmall Hotel4650 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050-23967.4 km from Pigeon Key#22 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesSmall Hotel1480 Overseas Highway Look for the Big Blue Chair and the American Flag, Marathon, FL 33050-21174.7 km from Pigeon Key#23 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see pricesMotel243 61st Street Gulf, Marathon, FL 33050-27028.7 km from Pigeon Key#26 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices1996 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 330505.1 km from Pigeon Key#27 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see pricesMotel8700 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050-323810.5 km from Pigeon Key#28 Best Value of 39 Hotels near Pigeon Key
- Enter dates to see prices
- Enter dates to see prices
Showing results 1-30 of 39
See what travellers are saying
- J1901DLtinac4 contributionsFun & Informative VisitThe whole experience was just wonderful from the “train” ride out through the volunteer guide that gave us so much history & information. The entire staff was pleasant and invested in the history @ preservation of Pigeon Key. Thank You for a truly wonderful experience.Thank you for your review! We are glad you enjoyed the train ride and tour.Written 2 November 2023This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited September 2023Travelled as a coupleWritten 3 October 2023
- Lou HKey Largo, Florida2 contributionsGreat tour!I live in Key Largo and haven't been to Pigeon Key in quite a few years. We had friends I town and decided to go take a tour and, what a great experience! The train driver, and tour guide were really knowledgeable and friendly with the customers and, I know from working in the tourist industry how hard that can be sometimes. The history that is there and the friendly attitude of the employees make this a must see for people coming through. Go see it! You won't be disappointed!We are so happy you visited our little island again!Written 2 November 2023This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited October 2023Travelled with friendsWritten 13 October 2023
- Angie P21 contributionsAmazing interesting and Fab afternoonThis was a fantastic afternoon and well worth a visit! We originally opted for a 230pm tour to walk the bridge. However we arrived to the parking lot early and swapped to the 1pm train! Which was easily swapped and not a bother! CT our guide was fab and really knowledgeable and we stayed and fed the sharks! Amazing, interesting A++++++Thank you for your review, Angie! We are glad you enjoyed your visit to the island.Written 2 November 2023This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited October 2023Travelled as a coupleWritten 16 October 2023
- SydneeSAPompano Beach, Florida105 contributionsStop at Pigeon Key and learn some Keys history. Fascinating.Always wanted too stop here and visiting with friends who are enjoying first visit to Keys was the perfect opportunity. Everyone so nice. History and the respect everyone has for the Flagler contributions is awe inspiring. CT was a great tour guide and knew her stuff. Wonderful experience.We are glad you enjoyed your trip to Pigeon Key!Written 2 November 2023This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited October 2023Travelled as a coupleWritten 20 October 2023
- Charlotte OKey West, Florida2 contributionsA great bit of historyWe have lived in Key West for years but never got around to visiting Pigeon Key. What a mistake! Now it’s on the top of me visitor list. The tour guide (CK?) was not only knowledgeable, she was fun. A terrific storyteller, and the Flagler and 7 Mille Bridge story is a great one. We took the little train, but it’s only 2 miles from the entrance to the island, so an easy walk or bike ride. They don’t have any food, but you can get a cold drink and there are very nice restrooms. We did the 2 hour trip but should really have stayed longer to experience everything. Don’t miss this if you are coming to the Keys.Thank you for your review! CT is a fantastic tour guide, and we are glad you enjoyed the island. It is always an option to take the train out and stay longer than the return time, as long as there is room on a later train!Written 2 November 2023This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited October 2023Travelled with familyWritten 25 October 2023
- James V1 contributionWell worth it!Great little tour, C.T as a guide was great! Julie our driver as well. Fascinating glimpse in to a little known area of Keys History. Beautiful island and facilities! Highly recommended!Thank you for the review James! We are glad you enjoyed your trip out to the island. Thank you for recommending us!Written 2 November 2023This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited October 2023Travelled with familyWritten 28 October 2023
- liquidjas39 contributionsVery Knowledgeable Tour GuideWe’ve been passing this place for years, so finally decided to check it out before heading to Key West for the day. The tour was only a couple hours long, and the tour guide was extremely knowledgeable about the property. It’s definitely worth checking out.Thank you for visiting! We are glad you enjoyed the tour and the history of the island.Written 2 November 2023This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited October 2023Travelled as a coupleWritten 31 October 2023
- Jill WSuffolk, Virginia4 contributionsGreat ExperienceThe tour was amazing! From the train ride over the old bridge out to the island, to our wonderful tour guide and his wealth of knowledge about the history of the island, it was enjoyable from start to finish! So glad we made this part of our vacation to the Keys!We are glad you enjoyed the tour of our little island!Written 8 February 2024This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited November 2023Travelled with friendsWritten 3 November 2023
- AmyGuard762 contributionsBeautiful Hidden GemBeautiful views. Our guide was great. She was informative and entertaining. Enjoyed seeing the old buildings as well. Will be back again. Opted to walk there and the view was worth it. Stopped to watch sting rays and saw a hammerhead shark.We are glad you enjoyed your tour of the island and thank you for recommending us!Written 8 February 2024This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited October 2023Travelled as a coupleWritten 3 November 2023
- Kathleen C1 contributionAwesome story around this island.This is such a hidden gem! (Actually not so hidden.) We saw the island from the 7 mile bridge and were very curious so went and checked it out. What an amazing history lesson and story of Henry Flagler. Our guide, C.T., is an awesome storyteller and made it all come to life. Great employees, fun train and beautiful views to boot! Take a couple hours to check it out.Thank you for stopping by!Written 8 February 2024This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.Visited November 2023Travelled as a coupleWritten 3 November 2023
These reviews are the subjective opinion of Tripadvisor members and not of TripAdvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Hotels near similar destinations
Seven Mile Bridge HotelsRead more
Old Seven Mile Bridge HotelsThe bridge re-opened after restoration on 1-12-2022. You can walk, bike or rollerblade the approximately 2.2 miles to Pigeon Key on the bridge and enjoy the amazing views. In the Florida Keys, there is no name better known than Henry Flagler who built the world-famous Oversea Railway in the early 1900's. Called the "8th Wonder of the World", this amazing ribbon of steel and concrete forever changed the history of the Florida Keys.Read more
San Pablo Catholic Church HotelsRead more
Marathon Visitors Center HotelsThe Islands of Marathon Visitor center is the official visitor center Middle Keys and Marathon area. We strive to provide high quality service to our guests. We offer free information about what to do, where to stay, where to dine, and more for our Middle and Florida Keys destinations. We look forward to serving you!Read more
Shady Palm Art Gallery & Frame Shop HotelsWe are located at MM 48.5 right in the middle of the Florida Keys. Our neighboring business is a coffee shop a perfect stop to stretch and come in for a visit. We feature over 50 local Florida Keys Artists with original paintings done in watercolor, oil, acrylic, ink and other types of mixed medium. We also offer matted prints, prints, canvas wraps, in all different sizes.Glass, pottery, carved wood, fine and fun jewelry, shell art, photography, lobster trap frames, driftwood, coconut art and much more. We offer custom framing with a digital mat cutter that can cut and inscribe letters and images. We hope to see you! Stop in and say hi!Read more
Monroe County Public Library, Marathon Branch HotelsThe Marathon Branch of the Monroe County Public Library system. Now located in our new building at 3490 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050Read more
Hotels Near Pigeon Key information
Hotels Near Pigeon Key, Marathon | There are 47 Hotels close to Pigeon Key in Marathon |
|---|---|
Hotels Near Pigeon Key Reviews | There are 24,106 reviews on Tripadvisor for Hotels nearby |
Hotels Near Pigeon Key Photos | There are 20,391 photos on Tripadvisor for Hotels nearby |
Nearest accommodation | 3.23 km |
Frequently Asked Questions about hotels near Pigeon Key
- Popular hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon that have a pool include:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club Marathon, Curio By Hilton - Traveller rating: 4/5
- Some of the best hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon are:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club Marathon, Curio By Hilton - Traveller rating: 4/5
- A gym is available to guests at the following hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club Marathon, Curio By Hilton - Traveller rating: 4/5
- A private balcony can be enjoyed by guests at the following hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Bluegreen The Hammocks at Marathon - Traveller rating: 4/5
- These hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon have great views and are well-liked by travellers:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Bluegreen The Hammocks at Marathon - Traveller rating: 4/5
- These hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon have been described as romantic by other travellers:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Isla Bella Beach Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5
- Families travelling in Marathon enjoyed their stay at the following hotels near Pigeon Key:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club Marathon, Curio By Hilton - Traveller rating: 4/5
- These hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon generally allow pets:Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club Marathon, Curio By Hilton - Traveller rating: 4/5Kingsail Resort - Traveller rating: 3.5/5Tropical Cottages - Traveller rating: 3.5/5It is always best to call ahead and confirm specific pet policies before your stay.
- These hotels near Pigeon Key in Marathon have free parking:Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Skipjack Resort & Marina - Traveller rating: 4/5Bluegreen The Hammocks at Marathon - Traveller rating: 4/5
- These 3 star hotels received great reviews from other travellers:Courtyard Faro Blanco Resort - Traveller rating: 4.5/5Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club Marathon, Curio By Hilton - Traveller rating: 4/5Bluegreen The Hammocks at Marathon - Traveller rating: 4/5